Hungry for Thanksgiving pie? But mixing sugar and flour just creates a powdery mess? No worries! These three Amish bakeries make the best pies in Sarasota. Order now, pick up Thursday morning and…Bon Appetit!

Detweiler Thanksgiving Pies

Detweiler’s Farm Market

Multiple Locations

Der Dutchman Thanksgiving Pies

Der Dutchman Market

3713 Bahia Vista Street

Yoder's Thanksgiving Pies


3434 Bahia Vista Street

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This